Geeklawyer got himself a HTC G1 from T-Mobile yesterday.
Now, as Geeklawyer has said many times before, he’s something of an Apple fanboy and the question is, therefore, what is wrong with the Apple 3G iPhone? Why the disloyalty? After all Geeklawyer has the latest iPod Touch which is a pretty spiffy sort of device. Why not drink the second bottle of Apple Kool-aid? Because Apple is degenerating into the maniacal monopolist that Microsoft was, before it became all flabby middle aged and got itself nailed for being technologically incompetent. That’s why. Apple could have made a shit hot iPhone and Touch. Instead Steve Jobs decided to suck phone-carrier cock. AT&T to be exact, though like a whore anyone’s money was good enough; it was just he asked too much and gave too little to get inside Verizon’s boxers. So not only did Steve suck, he swallowed in a manner that would have made Monika ‘blue dress’ Lewinsky ashamed of herself. He decided that by locking down the phone he could tie his buyers to a shit phone company, prevent them exercising choice and make himself big bucks. So, if you buy an Apple phone/Touch you get a heavily encrypted device you can’t hack. You want a feature? Ask Apple. You want an application? Go to the iTunes store. Got a great idea for a red-hot innovative application? Great. Spend an eternity developing it and hope Steve is in a good mood that day and decides to let you deliver it via iTunes. Just pray it doesn’t compete with anything Apple does ‘cos you’ll have wasted all that time and effort. You want to take a crap? Sign the Apple Toilet-Paper license first, pay, then stand in a long line to shit in an approved Apple Partner iToilet.
OK, the iPhone interface is very slick indeed. The hardware design is elegant. But take off the Oakley shades and you’ll see that the hardware is limited, the add-ons expensive the options limited. No removable media or battery, no FM radio, crap camera, no turn by turn navigation, bad bluetooth, ho-hum battery life. But above all what grates is the “Smile biatch, I’m about to do you in the ass
” attitude of Steve Jobs. So. The options? Geeklawyer has an N95 and it is a good phone. The GPS is sucky and so is the battery life. And Symbian S60 is a mid 90’s operating system which has a team of paramedics following it around it looks so ill. Geeklawyer had it for 18 happy months but he is not, barring disasters, looking at the N96.
Which leaves Google’s answer to the Jesus phone: the God Phone. Well OK that’s not entirely justified but it is potentially far more important than the iPhone.The iPhone is that pretty little lingerie model you picked up last night who’s conversation is: “erm, you know I just want to see, like, World peace because we all just have to get along, right?”. So you videoed yourself fucking her in the arse, then posted it on YouPorn.com and then couldn’t get her out of your apartment fast enough. The Googlephone by contrast is a coked up PhD student who is looking to ball you till your cock drops off, tell you how crap you are in bed, and then rip the intellectual heart out of your life’s ouvre; just as it was about to be published. A sort of subdued Ruthie in other words. And yes Google has far more potential to be a monopolist than Apple. The G1 is not perfect it is true. Apple fanboys, the other Apple fanboys that is, will witter on about how you need to to tap the screen to get a zoom button rather than the pinch feature of the iPhone. Yea pinching is nice. And I’d like it on the GodPhone, patents permitting, but frankly having used both it’s no deal breaker. the G1 screen is nice and the interface every bit as intuitive and slick as the iPhone, arguably more intuitive. The G’s hardware is slightly poorer in some respects: the battery life is marginally poorer on standby: Really though like most smartphones the battery life sucks and in this is fares no worse than the iPhone or the N95. I have yet to have the G1 out of chambers for any length of time so I can’t compare it in practise to the iPhone or N95 but I’d doubt it was much different. The GPS on the G1 is great. On the N95 one can get an accurate longtitude and latitude by pacing from the Royal Greenwich Observatory to one’s current position, in say Antartica, before the fucking N95 GPS gets a lock on a passing satellite. The G1 GPS locks on fast and it seems accurate. The G1 has a retarded headphone system: one needs a USB dongle to attach a headphone. who the fuck thought that was a good idea? A win for the iPhone. But a pretty small one. The N95 allowed it to be used as a tethered modem. One could tow around a laptop and use N95 to get net access. Very spiffy. By contrast the Apple OSx doesn’t even recognise the Googlephone as a phone. FAIL. Mind you, you can’t use the iPhone as a tethered modem either, since Apple won’t allow it’s partners to be robbed of a revenue stream: so it yanks such apps from the iTunes store (Not sure if this remains true as of time of writing — possible with jailbreaks & hacks? — blerch). Geeklawyer calls that a draw. So in many respects the iPhone and the Googlephone are evenly matched it would seem. At least it might seem that way if you didn’t understand that Google was playing rope-a-dope with Apple. Apple thinks it is clever. Justifiably so: because it is. But Google is way slicker. It is as evil as Apple, but it does it better and more subtly. Props Sergey, props. And here is the game changer: here is where Google has blind-sided dopey Apple:
- The Googlephone is open source. The core is Linux, open source. Google can’t be evil even if wants to (And in truth it probably does).
- The Android underpinnings of the Googlephone are open source and licensed to anyone and everyone. Only Apple makes the iPhone. So Nokia, Motorola HTC and my Uncle Bert can make an Android phone but only someone taking up the arse can build Steve’s phone.
The Android Market Place is open. Google doesn’t say “hey!! That’s a search engine application. Screw you, it might divert people from Google. App denied”. No. If Yahoo! or Microsoft want to built a search engine they can. The Android Market place is much more limited than iTunes,for now. Geeklawyer predicts it will pick up vibrabcy as people get to grips with coding for Android. Geeklawyer LOVES the apps on Android so far, and more is to come. Who wins now? Apple, just. But in 18 months/2 years Apple will be on the backfoot. Googlephone is the ultimate winner for sure. Even if you bitch about the HTC G1 the point is this: other phones from this and/or other manufacturers will come along. Some will have the iPhone features you like, others will have better. Further, once the Android software picks up, the Googlephone’s maturity will equal that of the iPhone.
Recent Comments