The End. In so many ways, the end.
This episode saw the downward spiral of the 24 caret plonker Ickbal from what seemed to be the unbreachable all time low of previous episodes. Never missing an opportunity to show that he was as dim as he was egotistical he offered numerous dishes to camera.
In a crowning articulation of the perils of upward social mobility Ickybal tells us that as a child he’d never dreamt of aspiring to the Bar imagining he’d exhaust his career in a West Midlands coal mine. Geeklawyer felt that even that lofty goal was a little above him, but at least being at the Bar he would not have been able to cave the roof in on his colleagues. Precious little consolation to those of us who might trip over his ego in the robing room.
On being given a wig to wear (“Wow, I’ve got a big head!” being a rare moment of self awareness) he improvised to camera: “My Lords I propose this case as a lot of bollocks.” Somehow one felt the inevitable anxiety that this was the exact and full quality of advice and advocacy that his punters would receive in his short lived career at the Bar before he retired to become an unlicensed cabbie in Birmingham: “I had that Lord Neuberger in the back of my cab the other day”.
Probably the highlight of his career was winning £271.32 from the Orange phone company as a litigant in person. Retarded Ikcbal proved well the adage that a lawyer who represents himself has a fool for a client: £271.32 did, however, seem like suitable highpoint on which to end his career.
Bizarrely, though, there were even bigger fools than Ikcbal on display. And while Ikbal has the defence of a low IQ youthful exuberance and the demonstrated limited capacity to utter anything other than vacuous piffle David Wolf had no such excuse.
Mr David Wolf practically exuded “oil of ‘ism’” aftershave from his pores. Geeklawyer wondered how he ever got to chambers in the morning so deep must be his bowel loosening fear of treading on an innocent fly or looking at a woman in a sexist non-supportive way on the Tube. Mr Wolf spent most of the episode wringing his hands in tearful angst at the ghastly elitism of the Bar. Matrix Chambers, he proudly declaimed, was engaged in organising a revolt at the Bar by which the bastions of privilege would be overthrown by having different coloured areas of chambers to correspond with different areas of practice.
“See? Green headed chambers notepaper matches the green walled area of chambers; you know when you are in the ‘Right-On’ part of Matrix, where we fight for the underdog at a very reasonable £300/hour”.
Oh, and they don’t have pupils, they have ‘Trainees’ who don’t ask clerks for help, they ask ‘Practice Assistants’. Matrix Chambers can be found at Griffin Building, Gray’s Inn. When Geeklawyer says at, he means above. Matrix Chambers is suspended about 300 foot above the ground: levitated on a cloud of its own virtuous, but inclusive and mutually supportive, hot self righteous air. Rumour has it that this will be powering the next generation of Zeppelin Airships.
Our last sight of Howlin’ Wolf was his shocked tut-tuting at the pomp of a House of Lord’s decision that went against his punter and how jolly elitist and inaccessible it was to the man in the street. He was cut short by the camera before saying the hearing should really have been before the Shoreditch Workers Peoples’ Collective Court. Mr Wolf then departed to get a breakfast of organic muesli and soy milk.
It was not all bad however. The delicious Cat, who can sit on Geeklawyer’s lap any time, got a puppyledge at Keating Chambers in London; and the funny sounding Northern Lass got a pupillage and tenancy in Newcastle. Spiffy — she seemed fairly competent and Geeklawyer wishes her well.
But if the pupils, aspirants and tenants seemed like a bunch of cunts then Kakoly Pande saved the day for the Bar. She exuded pure 24 carat charisma. Clever pretty modest and talented she exhibited the sort of self-confidence talent and class that made one doubt that she would ever fail at the Bar; fail and wind up becoming a Solicitor-Inadequate at the minor Midland solicitors Frisbees or somesuch career graveyard. Faced with objections from junior tenants as to her prospective tenancy she gave what seems to have been a bravura performance and won them over. Their objection was less to do with her than the shortage of work at the Bar: a common theme throughout the series, and rightly so.
Again, the larger and more important policy driven skirmishes between the Government and the Bar were not explored. This is not a criticism: a program such as this would not perform too well by exploring these issues.
Overall the fourth episode maintained the weaknesses of the previous episodes in that it didn’t step beyond the photogenic. Nonetheless it made for good television: it was engaging and interesting if not as good a reflection of the reality of the Bar as it could have been. One wonders if the public are any the wiser; Geeklawyer wouldn’t know, he tries to avoid them wherever possible.
you missed the ridiculous sympathy vote for “irritated old woman standing up to mean authorities” Served her right to pay costs for making me want to gouge out my eyeballs every time she spoke.
Geek, other bloggers and I have been wondering how common it is for one’s tenancy in chambers to be reviewed and challenged in the way that Kakoly’s was.
Is it more rife than we are lead to think?
I thought that whole episode with the delightful Miss Pande was awful but not entirely unpredictable. How could they do that to her, knowing that she is both in the middle of her first Crown Ct trial and being filmed? It doesn’t get much more stressful than that…A lot of barristers are shitheads. I haven’t heard of anyone being taken before the committee like that before but I have heard of someone who got recommended by the tenancy committee and then voted down by chambers. At least in that case they had the decency not to tell her she was in after the “first stage”. I thought the head of Kakoly’s chambers was a cowardly little man. If there are only 2 places for tenants, take two people on, not 4. And don’t say “well, they all know it’s subject to chambers ratification…” weakly, knowing full well that this was not the impression given to the wretched pupils. I have seen awful things at the Bar in relation to tenancy decisions — it’s certainly no science, and forget about being treated with an ounce of integrity or respect. Kakoly dealt with it so very brilliantly, I hope she manages to escape those bastards, I’d say she will…
I’d agree. When it comes to the head of chambers and his colleagues on the pupillage committee, they made themselves look very feeble minded and inadequate. Fancy going on camera saying the chambers could accommodate two new tenants and then selecting four instead. Moreover, who would want to instruct such a limp dick ?
Kakoly Pande was a class act throughout, and will surely get the last laugh. What newly practising counsel would not kill for the opportunity to advertise both a Crown Court success and their, seriously impressive, personal qualities on national telly.
Kakoly Pande was the star of the show and I hope she succeeds in achieving all of her ambitions. She is a fantastic advertisement for the modern criminal bar.
However, the rest of the programme was so dull. Where was Dickie?? He may look like an 80 year old but at least he has a sense of humour and stood up to that ridiculous man in the robbery trial. I was in Warwick Corwn Court last week and the general view in the robing room was that he is actually a nice chap, quite good at his job and is slightly naughty when it comes to his sense of humour. Bring him back!!!
“Where was Dickie?” Damed straight. The star of the series in Geeklawyer’s view (tho’ 80 seems a bit cruel — a laboured 40 perhaps). Glad to hear the Warwick Robing Room has confirmed our assessment of Dickie as a decent fellow.
Dickie!! Don’t be shy pipe up — your audience awaits!
I once had the pleasure of meeting the ‘trainee’ from Matrix shown on the programme, on the damnable and soporific forensic accounting course. Fear not GL, she may have sat there and gently nodded while her pupil-master (bet they wince at that word) talked about how awfully modern they all were, but in person she scared the bejeezus out of me, in a very old-fashioned and ruthless barrister-like way.
My Dear Geek,
Again the wig-wearers managed to score plenty of own goals.
Great post, few laugh out loud moments, in particular about the Iqbal chap. Forgetting the perennial shit-eating grin on that face (displaying the sort of self-satisfaction which would make even Jack Nicholson re-evaluate), the greatest offence was that the guy clearly thought he was some sort of poster boy for the ‘modern Bar’, because he happened to reside in (or, more probably, nearish) an area which wasn’t overwhelmingly middle class. Never mind the fact that this trailblazer on more than one occasion made reference to woefully anachronistic depictions of his birthplace. A complete pile of shit — if that man is the future of the Bar, then the need for reform is even more desperate than anyone thought.
Wasn’t surprised in the slightest that Cat got a pupillage, simply because she’d developed the sort of contacts that a degree of nepotism could intervene. She was clearly very committed and intelligent, so good luck to her. That said, you got the sense that the decision by Keating was somewhat based on a cost-benefit analysis — the silk was representing Chambers, there was an opportunity to provide a happy ending on national television and that may have overridden any concerns which may have otherwise proved intractable.