As mentioned previously Geeklawyer did a bit of minor criminal work recently: a bail application before a Crown Court judge. It was interesting to see how the other half live. The robing room was a pit of miserable despair; Legal aid barristers with 6 o’clock shadows (including some females) hovered around in threadbare suits several decades old and cheap scuffed shoes. Geeklawyer is sure that he noticed more than one who appeared to be drinking tins of white lightning cider out of brown paper bags. Female solicitor-advocates fed gin to their mewling brats to quieten them in the back of the court.
Geeklawyer was a trifle alarmed at his brief, both in its prospects and its timing. His head of chambers was unable to get the papers from instructing solicitors until late at night despite a court appearance being first on the list at 9.45am the following morning. This is, apparently, fairly standard. How the devil is a chap supposed to do a decent job when given mere hours notice to read 30 odd pages of instructions? What if Geeklawyer had been going out to dinner that night? Truly, Geeklawyer thinks, the criminal Bar is a fucked up place and he pities its denizens.
The instructions themselves were a pitiful tale. Some vile cur had spent two years battering his wife while in an alcoholic daze. Finally his wife was provoked to complain about him but the system gave him bail until he appears to have decided it was inconvenient and he had better things to do than turn up to court. Arrest followed as inevitably as pupilettes offering sexual favours for a pupillage. On the face of it then the prospect was of attempting to obtain bail for a fellow who had nowhere else to go but back to the marital home and a wife he beat-up and who was an alcoholic prospectively abroad at xmas when more alcohol than normal is consumed. Not a promising brief it would seem.
Geeklawyer is very proud that he managed to get him unconditional bail with minimal advocacy. After obtaining bail and being released by the judge Geeklawyer expressed, in passing, his pleasure at success obtained while not having to engage in much oratory. The judge flashed back:
“Yes Mr [Geeklawyer] I usually find that’s for the best”
He was an amiable witty old chap and since the put-down was not directed at Geeklawyer but to the derelicts (barristers that is, not defendants) he normally had before him Geeklawyer felt disinclined to destroy him for such impudence.
Excellent — another criminal back on the streets. Us derelicts are grateful.
As putdowns go, nothing beats a colleague of mine who faced with an unpleasant judge finally cracked when the judge said “Mr X, you are demonstrating contempt for the Court” and replied “Not at all my Lord. I am trying to conceal it”.
Bwah haha
That goes into the armoury.
My personal favourite was the reply to a judge who failed to comprehend an argument after much repetition:
J. “I m sorry Mr [X] I am none the wiser“
Counsel: “No my Lord, but you are better informed”